Another article came out today by Sarah Seltzer in Time Magazine that looked at the trend of Jewish leading roles going to non-Jewish actresses while the stereotypical roles go to Jewish actors. This is something that Sarah Silverman was one of the first to mention on Howard Stern and then later again on her own show. However, what they looked at was a few cases and could easily be dismissed by mentioning some of the leading roles that are played by Jewish actors.
However, I am a scientist and I decided to look at the data. I looked at the IMDB Jewish Films as well as the Holocaust films and Wikipedia and any other films I could find. Thus I compiled a list of 57 films, far more than the 30 needed to create a statistically significant sample size and I found that the Sarah Silverman hypothesis rings true and can be called the Sarah Silverman Theory of American Antisemitism in Films and Roles, but there was also so much more.
First is first. It is true. Jews are less likely to be cast in Jewish leading roles. Now while overall, Jewish characters that are portrayed in films are more positive and strong than weak and negative, the roles that are given to Jewish actors are more likely to be ones that are seen as weak or negative, thus re-enforcing stereotypes.
Since Sarah Silverman focused on women’s roles, I decided to look if there was any impact of gender on the roles, and boy was there. Not only are there far fewer roles for Jewish women as there are fewer Jewish women’s roles (18% to 82%), but the ones which had non-Jewish actresses were all strong while 66% of Jewish roles with Jewish actresses were strong. Then while 90% of all women’s Jewish characters were positive, when played by Jewish actresses, that percentage went down to 67% while remaining 90% for non-Jewish actresses.
However, the data does not show something that is even more pernicious. The roles that are played by non-Jewish actors will often go out of their way to erase the Jewishness of the roles. For instance, the role of Kenneth Feinberg in Worth played by Michael Keaton completely erased the Jewishness of the character. Gone from the role was any semblance of the New York Jew that can be seen in the actual person. In fact, one would not know the character is Jewish if not for the one antisemitic insult made during the movie.
Then there is a movie like Awakenings with Robin Williams. Jewish-passing actors like Robin Williams and Ben Kingsley have stolen more Jewish roles than Matzah on Passover. In this film, the writers go out of their way to erase all Jewishness from the real-life character Oliver Sacks who discovered the cure to the horrible locked-in syndrome. The film changed the name and then in the ending credits went on to say that Dr. Sayer, not Dr. Sacks continues to practice medicine, erasing the Jewishness of the person and thus their contribution to America.
So why are stereotypes of Jews so bad? Well, maybe because of movies like Madoff and Dopesick where Jewish characters are evil while in movies like Worth or Awakenings their Jewishness is erased or Wonderful Mrs. Mazel where the Jewishness is used more like an ornament or a Halloween costume.
The end effect is not only the limiting of Jewish actors from positive Jewish roles but the added re-enforcement of Jewish stereotypes that continues to put Jewish Americans in danger as the number one attacked minority in United States as a percentage of hate crimes. And because American culture is shown and spread around the world, so do the stereotypes and the hate.
With the added visibility of these practices, I hope that more Jewish actors are afforded these roles because Jewishness is not a religion, it is an ethnicity and it cannot be impersonated no more than being Indian by a Mexican or Italian by a Norwegian.